While there is an increasing conflict about the meaning of Oscars, a constant debate rising at this point is whether acknowledgement in the West spells more success in the East. Whenever an actor performs to his greatest potential, the next slogan that immediately flashes out is ‘oscar like performance’. Even after 50 years of freedom, there seems to be this restless and incessant longing for occidental approval.
India has been a leading contributor in International Cinema, with over 500 films being released a year. It is very disappointing to know that, despite being such a strong forerunner, many Indians ascribe so much value, integrity, hype and hoopla to the Oscars. However, the truth is that the Oscars are the epitome of recognition for cinema, and often translates into opulence for those who return with it. The success of Lagaan and the consequent development of the Indian film industry is testament to just how crucial Oscars are in filmdom. The reason why Slumdog Millionaire cannot be substantiated as an example is because it did not win on the grounds of how it portrayed India. It was definitely a story of triumph against all odds, but it was backed by technically slick production, and direction by a person of great credentials. Slumdog Millionaire also had its back by the strong Fox and Dreamworks organisation.
The Indian film industry is hugely talented, and as of late has become world-class. It deserves to be represented and recognized all over the world. It further acts as a medium to educate the world about Indian culture, its heritage and contemporary India. Surprising is the amount of ignorance others in the world have about India. India has such a rich and colourful culture, such beautiful and sublime philosophies and spirituality that the world should be introduced to, especially in this age. Why do we have to look westwards for ideas? This is why Lagaan and the fatigue-inducing Devdas were chosen to represent India at the Oscars, because they are synonymous of our culture and our storytelling traditions. The Producers Association (who recommends Indian films for Academy Awards) did not consider Satyajit Ray, Mrinal Sen or Adoor Gopalakrishnan films Oscar-worthy. Films like Pather Panchali, Apur Sansar, Aparajito, Charulata, Bhuvan Shome or Mathilukal were ignored. This leaves much to be pondered over the selection of films.
With the increasing interest in Indian cinema in the West perhaps a day might dawn when Indian movies would proudly march all the way to Los Angeles for justifiably competing for the Oscar Awards and returning home with the much coveted statuette. Maybe some time in the future, some day, it would happen. Indian filmmakers should also learn to treat the Oscars with the required attention only. And also to learn that our films can give Hollywood productions a run for their money in all countries. Sholay and Nayagan didn’t need an Academy Award stamp to certify that they are as ripping a good yarn as The Godfather.
You can read up this excellent article on how The Academy forcefully forgets Asian Cinema.
